Call To The Bullpen
Call To The Bullpen
The Investment Thesis vs. Reality: Why Acquisitions Miss the Mark
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Every acquisition starts with an investment thesis. Most of them live in a spreadsheet, and that is exactly where the trouble starts.
In Episode 19, Clint Overton and Ted Stann dig into the gap between the thesis an acquirer builds before close and what actually happens once they own the business. Drawing on deals they have watched succeed and deals they have watched fail, they break down why value creation plans so often fall short and what disciplined acquirers do differently.
In this episode:
- Why the numbers have to be realistic, not aspirational
- The human side of the thesis: talent, culture, and systems integration
- Why you should talk to the target's customers before you close
- Being honest with the selling CEO about what will change (process, systems, people)
- How a "don't disrupt anything" posture leaves acquirers playing defense a year in
- A real acquisition that failed over pricing, lost clients, and a departing CEO
- Why private equity hold periods are stretching from four or five years toward seven to ten
Whether you are a family business pursuing add-ons, an independent sponsor, or part of a PE firm actively acquiring, this conversation is a practical gut check on your next deal.
Learn more at boardroombullpen.com and themercurycollective.com.